Skip to main content

Judge Likely To Rule In Mariah Carey’s Favor In Christmas Song Copyright Case

Photo: Mariah Carey/Instagram

Mariah Carey’s famous holiday song, "All I Want for Christmas Is You," has been at the center of a legal battle. Mississippi artist Vince Vance, known for his 1989 song of the same name, claims that Carey copied his work. However, after a long process, a California judge is leaning toward dismissing the case.

This case started in 2022, when Vance filed a lawsuit saying that Carey’s hit song copied his song’s style and structure. After the first case was dropped, Vance filed again, claiming Carey took the idea and “pretended” it was hers.

Carey’s lawyers, on the other hand, argue that any similarities between the songs are just holiday themes like "Santa Claus" and "mistletoe," which are common in Christmas songs. They say these themes are public property, and the two songs are not substantially similar.

Photo: Mariah Carey/Instagram

At a recent court hearing, Judge Mónica Ramírez Almadani said she is likely to agree with Carey’s side, which could mean the case will be dropped soon. The judge is also considering a separate request from Carey’s team to penalize Vance’s side for filing what they say is a “frivolous” lawsuit.

The judge hasn’t made a final decision yet, but if she does dismiss the case, Carey’s holiday hit will continue to play on for fans without legal trouble.

Carey’s song, first released in 1994, has become a holiday classic and even reached No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 multiple times during the holiday season. Source 

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Anthony Edwards' Dunk Over Kevin Durant at Olympic Practice Goes Viral

Photo: Instagram/Anthony Edwards A stunning sports photo has taken over the internet and is sure to be remembered for a long time. Photographer Garrett W. Ellwood captured the iconic moment on Thursday before the 2024 Olympic Games in Paris. During Team USA's practice, Anthony Edwards of the Minnesota Timberwolves, playing in his first Olympics, delivered a powerful dunk over Phoenix Suns star Kevin Durant . Ellwood was in the perfect spot to snap the shot. Photo: Instagram/Anthony Edwards Durant joked about the photo on social media after seeing it. This isn’t the first time Edwards and Durant have had a viral moment. In April, during Game 1 of the Timberwolves-Suns playoff series, Edwards taunted Durant by jogging backward down the court. friendly fire. 👀 pic.twitter.com/QlhXdNi7U9 — Minnesota Timberwolves (@Timberwolves) July 25, 2024 The Timberwolves won that game 120-95 and swept the Suns in four games. Durant, Edwards, and Team USA will start their Olympic journey on...
Post a Comment
Read More

Billie Eilish Yanked Into Crowd By Fan In Shocking Miami Concert Moment

Photo: Billie Eilish / Instagram   Billie Eilish’s meet-and-greet moment with fans took a scary turn when a concertgoer pulled her into the crowd during her Miami show.  The “Birds of a Feather” singer was walking along the barricade handing out high fives after performing “Guess” when a fan suddenly yanked her down.  Videos posted on TikTok show the 23-year-old falling beside the blockade as nearby fans gasped in shock.  Photo: Billie Eilish / Instagram Security quickly rushed in to push the person back while Eilish stood up and continued walking, looking visibly upset.   Despite the scare, she kept performing and went back to greeting fans shortly after.  Miami Police confirmed the person was ejected from the Kaseya Center, with one fan claiming on TikTok that the man was later arrested.  Fans online expressed anger and concern, saying the incident might cause Eilish to increase security at her next shows.  Eilish has not yet commented on the in...
Post a Comment
Read More

Patrick Mahomes' Father Arrested For DWI Days Before Chiefs' Super Bowl Clash

Photo: Instagram/Patrick Mahomes Patrick Mahomes Sr., father of star quarterback Patrick Mahomes , has been arrested for suspicion of driving while intoxicated, marking his third offense, just days ahead of the Chiefs' Super Bowl showdown against the San Francisco 49ers. Mahomes Sr. previously faced DWI charges in 2018, resulting in a guilty plea and a 40-day jail term.  His history includes DUI charges in 1994 and an arrest for public intoxication in 2016 during a game between TCU and Texas Tech, where his son played college football. Photo: Instagram/Patrick Mahomes Sr. With the arrest coming a week before the pivotal game in Las Vegas, questions arise about Mahomes Sr.'s attendance. Despite his previous plans to be there, the incident adds an unexpected twist to the Chiefs' preparations. Patrick Mahomes, seeking his third ring in just seven seasons, has garnered praise from his father, who acknowledges the rarity of such success.  However, Mahomes Sr. refrains from placi...
Post a Comment
Read More